...
| Comment # | Document (Policy / MRPS) | Document line / reference | Proposed Change or Query | Proposer / Affiliation | Candidate response |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Policy | all pages | Please add page numbers to the document, if possible | Mario Reale/GÈANT | |
| 2 | Policy | page 19 | Between items 3.2 and 3.3 there is an "If" a the beginning of 3.3. that is shared/mixed up. Clearly a typo | Mario Reale/GÈANT | |
| 3 | Policy | page 13 | Section 4.2.4: please add a reference the ngREN webiste URL (hyperlink in the digital document) | Mario Reale/GÈANT | |
| 4 | Policy | page 8 | Section 4.3: please make it an hyperlink inside the digital document | Mario Reale/GÈANT | |
| 5 | Policy | page 14 | Section 5.1.1: "he governing body" should be "The governing body" | Mario Reale/GÈANT | |
| 6 | Policy | In section 5, there should be on the website, correctly - it's just that the how to join as a SP is not in the policy document). | I think there is no section on how to join the federation as a Service Provider | Mario Reale/GÈANT | |
| 7 | Policy | Definition & Terminology - NgRENID | Probably a typo, but the description doesn't match the terminology. Shouldn't it be NgRENIF? | Casper Dreef/GÉANT | |
| 8 | Policy | all pages | Font and layout consistency. | Casper Dreef/GÉANT | |
| 9 | Policy | All pages | Using bullets instead of subparagraphs (e.g 3.1.1) improves readability. | Casper Dreef/GÉANT | |
| 10 | Policy | Introduction | Unnecessary use of numbered paragraphs | Casper Dreef/GÉANT | |
| 11 | Policy | 3.1.12; 3.2.7; 3.4.6 | How would this process works? Also wrt 3.2.7 and 3.4.6? | Casper Dreef/GÉANT | |
| 12 | Policy | 3.2.4 | Typo NGREN → NgREN | Casper Dreef/GÉANT | |
| 13 | Policy | 3.5.2 | Is this optional (should) or obligatory (must)? | Casper Dreef/GÉANT | |
| 14 | Policy | 5.2 | Will there be a standard termination period? | Casper Dreef/GÉANT | |
| 15 | Policy | 6.2.8 | Specify "neither party" | Casper Dreef/GÉANT | |
| 16 | Policy | 3.1 | "Develop a Standard Data Protection Policy Template to be adopted with/without modifications by the Federation Members." is a short-term action. By adding "Develop and maintain..." it becomes something that is not a one shot. | Pål Axelsson/Sunet | |
| 17 | Policy | 3.1 | Under section 3.2 there is in the fifth bullet a mention of maintain contact around inter-federation. But there is no mention on who has the responsibility around inter-federation membership. That should be with the governing body. | Pål Axelsson/Sunet | |
| 18 | Policy | 5.1 | Last bullet that starts with "However, " should be part of 4.3, or 4.4, were eligibility of membership is defined. | Pål Axelsson/Sunet | |
| 19 | Policy | Appendix 1 6.3 iii | In this bullet Co-Federation is used, is that something else than inter-federation? | Pål Axelsson/Sunet | |
| 20 | Policy | Appendix 1 7.3 Metadata Distribution | Add signed on the right place. For example "NgRENID publishes singed Metadata" and "NgRENID may also make a signed subset of the Metadata" | Pål Axelsson/Sunet | |
| 21 | Policy | Appendix 3 3.3 | The term Co-Federation is used here, see comment 19. | Pål Axelsson/Sunet | |
| 22 | Policy | Appendix 4 2.1 | It mentions three classes of members but I can only see two. Maybe it's based on the last bullet in the section is on the wrong level. | Pål Axelsson/Sunet | |
| 23 | MRPS | 5 | Defintion of registration of DNS based scope is missing. The scope registration for identity providers is mandatory and if it's missing attributs may be automatically filter by services. | Pål Axelsson/Sunet |