This workflow provides an example scenario of how the proposed Basic service offering would help a research collaboration when editing a shared wiki belonging to the collaboration.

The scenario hypothesises three types of end users:

• An operator who is in charge of managing membership of the collaborations' users;

• A user called “Alice”, who is a collaboration user who can login using a home institution account; and

• A user called “Bob”, who is a collaboration user who has no home institution.

In order to complete this scenario successfully, the following tasks need to be accomplished:

1. Alice and Bob need access to a wiki service,

2. the wiki service requires authorisation in the context of the research collaboration as only some members of the collaboration are allowed in,

3. the operator has been given the authorisation to manage members in the membership management service,

4. Alice has the role of "wiki space admins" within the research collaboration which makes her the manager of a space in the wiki service, and she has been delegated the ability to manage members of the "wiki space editors" group,

5. Bob becomes a member of the "wiki space editors" group and is able to edit the content in the wiki service.

To execute this flow, the operator first needs to be able to make the Alice and Bob members of the research collaboration. To this end, the  operator uses the Membership management service to make users members of the research collaboration by issuing invites. In response to the invite, the users should log in to the Membership management service and provide some basic attributes ie. information necessary to decide if they should access the service.

It is assumed that Alice will log in using a federated login authenticated via her home institution which is available in eduGAIN. Bob has no home institution, and therefore uses an External ID provider to log in with his Google ID. The operator evaluates the information received about the users and makes them members of the research collaboration. As they have membership, both users are assigned a Persistent Identifier, which is specific for this research collaboration. With the Persistent Identifier assigned to them, both users can now authenticate at services provided within the context of the research collaboration.

However, the collaboration may have services they want to restrict to only some members based on role in the collaboration. Therefore, to determine whether they have any roles within the context of the research collaboration, the wiki services queries the membership management service and the Simple Groups service. To assign Alice the "wiki space admin" role, the operator can add her to the appropriate group. This group is managed with the Simple Groups service by the  operator. After being assigned group membership of the "wiki space admins", can Alice log into the Simple Groups service, and add Bob to the "wiki space editors" group.

The development team first looked at the use cases of several major pan-European eScience communities, Research Infrastructures and e-Learning collaborations in terms of their use of federated authentication and identifies the needs and challenges they are facing. In the initial phase of the project, an open survey was set up allowing any community to specify requirements and highlight the challenges they are facing. The survey was publicised at key events and on mailing lists and by direct invite to participate. In addition to this survey, the project team also conducted a study of the AAI infrastructures currently used or planned in Europe so that the needs of communities  of different sizes and involved in different e-science disciplines were understood. VOs in the field of learning were also included. The requirements listed in the Federated Identity Management for research communities (FIM4R) paper [FIM4R] were also assessed. The development team then reviewed all the requirements to find commonalities and derive a set of generalised requirements across the various communities.

These requirements were segmented into two service offerings, Basic and Advanced.

Once the requirements were defined and segmented, the team analysed a combination of commercial, open source, federation and custom developed components to determine which best met the requirements for the basic service, before designing an architecture, implementing integration and carrying out custom development, contributing upstream to existing open source developments where they were chosen. The final steps are integration, packaging and pre-pilot testing. For the advanced service, a research collaboration will have the opportunity to specify some particular components to be included.