Page History

Decisions of the eSG are determined by a simple majority of Member Federations from the active list at the time of the call to vote, apart from constitutional changes. Member Federations may vote on all constitutional changes and new Technology Profiles but may only vote on changes to Technical Profiles in active use within their federations. Each Member Federation’s vote is equal, and each Member Federation is initially regarded as active. A Member Federation which is absent from two consecutive votes will be removed from the active list for the purpose of subsequent votes. Participating in a vote returns the federation to the active list.Voting takes place over two weeks, but a decision may be reached early if the required majority is achieved before that time.

activeNoexcludedNoYesexcludedNoYesactiveNoNoGRNETactiveNoNoYeseduId.huNoactiveYesYesYesYesIDEMactiveYesYesYesLAIFEactiveNoYeseduID LuxNoNoLEAFYesYesYesYesYesYesFEIDEactiveYesYesYesRCTSaaiactiveNoNoArnesAAIexcludedNoNoSIRexcludedactiveYesYesNoInCommonactiveexcludedNoNoMATEactiveNoYesNoGrid Identity PoolYesnon-memberTuakiriexcludedNoNoNoOman KIDexcludedYETKIM

Federation	Voting Status	2020-05 (safeID and CSTCloud)	2019-10* (KRENA)	2019-09 (RiċerkaNet)	2019-06 (Maeen)	2019-05 (LIAF, RoEduNetID & CARSI)	2018-12 (Albania and eduID.rah.al)	2018-11 (PKIFed)	2018-10 (FIDERN)	2018-08 (eduIDM.ma and CAFMoz)	2018-07 (SIFULAN)	2018-04 (RUNnet-AAI)	2018-01 (RIF)	2017-10	2017-07	2017-06
AFIRE	excluded	No	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	No	Yes	No	Yes
AAF	active	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Federation	Voting Status	2017-07	2017-06	2017-02	v3 Const	2016-12	2016-11	2016-07
AFIRE	active	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	No
AAF	active	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No
ACOnet Id Fed	active	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No
Belnet Federation	excluded	No	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes
CAFe	active	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No
CAF	active	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
COFRe	active	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No
COLFIRE	excluded	No	No	No	No	No	No	No
AAI@EduHr		Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes
ACOnet Id FededuID.cz	active	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	WAYF	excluded	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes
MINGABelnet Federation	active	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes	No	No	TAAT	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	No
HAKACAFe	excluded	No	No	No	Yes	No	No	No	FER	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	Grena Id Fed	No	YesYes
CAF	active	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	DFN AAI	active	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes		Yes
COFRe	active	Yes	No	active	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Edugate	excluded	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes
IUCC Id FedCOLFIRE	excluded	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	Yes
GakuNinAAI@EduHr	active	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
No	LITNET FEDIeduID.cz	active		No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	active	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yesactive	No
WAYF	excluded	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	No	No	No	No
PIONIER.IdMINGA	active	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes
TAAT	active	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No
HAKA	active	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No
SWAMIDFER	active	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	SWITCHaai	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No
Grena Id Fed	SURFconext	active	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes		Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	YesYes
DFN AAIPEANO	active	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes
GRNETUK Federation	active	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes
eduId.hu	FEBAS	active	No	Yes		Yes	Yes	No	No	No	active	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes
Edugate	active	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	No	No
IUCC Id Fed	active	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes
IDEM	active	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	excluded	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	No	No
KAFE	active	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	non-member	non-member
AAIEduMk	excluded	No	No	Yes	Yes	non-member	non-member	non-member
SAFIRE	active	Yes	No	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member
INFED	active	Yes	Yes	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member
SGAF	active	Yes	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member
ARNaai	active	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member
CIF	active	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member
IRFED	active	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member	non-member
Total	38	27 (26)	30 (29)	31 (30)	38	26 (17)	29	11
active	Active voting member and able to participate in the next vote.
active	Active voting member, did not participate in the last vote, will become "excluded" if vote not cast at next vote.
excluded	Inactive voting member, has missed both of the previous 2 votes, should vote "I abstain" at next vote to become active.
Yes	Vote cast (does not indicate Postive, Abstain or Negative position of the vote).
Yes	Vote cast by previously "excluded" voting member (does not count toward outcome).
No	Did not cast a vote.
non-member	Not an eduGAIN member and thus ineligible to vote

Table of Contents

outline	true
style	none

Summary of votes by the eduGAIN SG

2012

Belnet welcomed to edugain (2012). No vote required under constitution at this time.

2013

Yes

No

GakuNin

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

LAIFE

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

LITNET FEDI

active

Yes

No

eduID.lu

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

LEAF

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

FEIDE

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

PIONIER.Id

excluded

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

RCTSaai

active

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

ArnesAAI

excluded

No

SIR

excluded

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

SWAMID

active

Yes

SWITCHaai

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

SURFconext

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

InCommon

active

Yes

PEANO

excluded

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

UK Federation

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

MATE

excluded

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

FEBAS

active

yes

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

Grid Identity Pool

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

Tuakiri

excluded

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Oman KID

excluded

No

Yes

No

YETKIM

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

KAFE

active

Yes

No

Yes

AAIEduMk

excluded

No

Yes

No

SAFIRE

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

INFED

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

SGAF

active

No

Yes

non-member

ARNaai

active

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

non-member

CyNet Identity Federation

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

non-member

IRFED

active

Yes

non-member

BIF

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

non-member

HKAF

active

Yes

No

Yes

non-member

RIF

active

Yes

No

Yes

non-member

RUNNet-AAI

active

yes

Yes

non-member

SIFULAN

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

non-member

eduIDM.ma

excluded

No

non-member

CAFMoz

excluded

No

non-member

FIDERN

excluded

No

non-member

OMREN Fed

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

non-member

фEDUrus

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

non-member

PKIFED

active

Yes

No

Yes

No

non-member

RASH

excluded

No

non-member

RoEduNetID

active

Yes

No

non-member

LIAF

active

Yes

No

Yes

non-member

CARSI

excluded

No

non-member

Maeen

excluded

No

Yes

non-member

RiċerkaNet

active

Yes

No

non-member

KIF

active

No

non-member

CSTCloudFederation

active

non-member

SafeID

active

non-member

Total

54

44 (41)

30 (29)

46 (46)

39 (35)

44 (38)

33 (28)

25 (24)

47 (40)

39 (33)

38 (29)

42 (34)

32 (29)

31 (22)

27 (26)

30 (29)

active	Active voting member and able to participate in the next vote.
active	Active voting member, did not participate in the last vote, will become "excluded" if vote not cast at next vote.
excluded	Inactive voting member, has missed both of the previous 2 votes, should vote "I abstain" at next vote to become active.
Yes	Vote cast (does not indicate Postive, Abstain or Negative position of the vote).
Yes	Vote cast by previously "excluded" voting member (does not count toward outcome).
No	Did not cast a vote.
non-member	Not an eduGAIN member and thus ineligible to vote

Table of Contents

outline	true
style	none

Summary of votes by the eduGAIN SG

2012

Belnet welcomed to edugain (2012). No vote required under constitution at this time.

2013

Vote on an update to the eduGAIN Policy Framework: https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-Policy-Update-20130409-5163e A 2/3 majority was required of the active federations. 21 votes were cast and all were in the affirmative.
COFRE welcomed to edugain (October 2013).
ArnesAAI welcomed to edugain (October 2013).
Vote to accept PIONIER.Id federation as a member of eduGAIN: https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-27-Nov-2013-5294c 28 federations were active, 16 votes were cast and all were in the affirmative.

2014

Vote to accept IUCC Identity Federation (IIF) as a member of eduGAIN: http://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-20-June-2014-53a2d 31 federations were active, 11 votes cas and all were in the affirmative.
Vote to accept Argentina/MATE managed by INNOVA|RED, Colombia/ColFIRE managed by RENATA and Ecuador/MINGA managed by CEDIA as members of eduGAIN: https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-16-September-2014-5417d 33 federations were active, 11 votes were cast, 1 abstain on COLFIRE, all remaining were in the affirmative.

2015

Vote to accept PEANO: https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-PEANO-Ukraine-16-March-2015-5506b. 36 federations were active, 13 votes were received and all were in the affirmative.
Slovakia? Mentioned in July 2015.
Macedonia? Mentioned in July 2015.
Vote to accept eduID Luxembourg: [false http://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-eduID-Luxembourg-8-July-2015-559d2]. 41 federations were active, 15 votes were cast, all were in the affirmative.
Vote to accept Oman KID: https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-Oman-KID-11-November-2015-56436 42 federations were active, 10 votes cast and all were in the affirmative.

2016

Vote to accept Grid Identity Pool (GrIdP) https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-Grid-Identity-Pool-GrIdP-27-July-2016-57987 41 federations were active, 11 votes cast and all were in the affirmative.
Vote to accept KAFE https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-17-November-2016-582d9 21 federations were active voting members, 14 votes cast from active members in the affirmative. 15 votes cast by excluded voters.
Vote to accept AAIEduMk https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-6-December-2016-58469 33 federations were active voting members, 17 votes cast from active members, 16 in the affirmative. 9 votes cast by excluded voters and 1 duplicate vote.
Vote to accept an update to the eduGAIN Constitution to v3 https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-Constitution-v3-Update-585c1 As this is a constitution update all 46 members are able to vote (as per v2 of the Constitution).There were 39 votes in total, 36 in the affirmative, 31 needed to reach a 2/3 majority (which was achieved), 1 duplicate vote and 2 abstentions.

2017

Vote to accept SAFIRE and INFED https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-15-February-2017-58a16 43 federations were active voting members, 30 votes cast from active members, 28 in the affirmative for SAFIRE, 27 in the affirmative for INFED, 1 vote from excluded voter and 1 duplicate vote.
Vote to accept SGAF https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-15-June-2017-59427 44 federations were active voting members, 30 votes cast from active members, 24 in the affirmative for SGAF, 5 abstain, 1 vote from excluded voter.
Vote to accept ARNaai, CIF and IRFED https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-31-July-2017-597ee 42 federations were active voting members, 26 votes cast from active members, 25 in the affirmative for ARNaai, 22 in the affirmative for CIF, 22 in the affirmative for IRFED, 1 vote from an excluded voter.
Vote to accept BIF and HKAF Vote on an update to the eduGAIN Policy Framework: https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-Policy12-UpdateOctober-20130409-5163e A 2/3 majority was required of the active federations. 21 votes were cast and all were in the affirmative.
COFRE welcomed to edugain (October 2013).
ArnesAAI welcomed to edugain (October 2013).

Vote to accept PIONIER.Id federation as a member of eduGAIN:

2017-59df8 38 federations were active voting members, 26 votes cast from active members, 22 in the affirmative, 1 duplicate vote (as "I abstain").

2018

Vote to accept RIF https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-

...

15-

...

January-

...

2018-

...

5a5cd 42 federations were active voting members,

...

29 votes

...

cast

...

from active members, all

...

in the affirmative

...

, 3 abstain from excluded voter to regain voting rights.
Vote to accept

...

RUNNet-AAI https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-

...

Russia-

...

RUNNet-

...

AAI-

...

5abe1 42 federations were active voting members,

...

34 votes cast from active members, 31 in the affirmative, 3 abstain, 1 vote cast by an unidentified voter and 8 abstain from excluded voters to regain voting rights.
Vote to accept

...

SIFULAN https://

...

evento.renater.fr/survey/results/tyhqyelc 46 federations were active voting members,

...

34 votes

...

cast from active members, 29 in the affirmative, 5 abstain and 4 abstain from excluded voters to regain voting rights (and 2 "test" votes registered as "I abstain").
Vote to accept eduIDM.ma and CAFMoz https://evento.renater.fr/survey/results/gn5hvaey 50 federations were active voting members, 38 votes cast from active members, 33 in the affirmative, 5 abstain in total and 1 abstain from excluded voters to regain voting rights and 1 miscast vote from excluded voter (which should have been an abstain).
Vote to accept OMREN Fed, фEDUrus & FIDERN https://evento.renater.fr/survey/results/c77oeex3 48 federations were active voting members, 47 votes cast from active members, 35/33/35 in the affirmative, 14/16/14 abstain in total and 7 abstain from excluded voters to regain voting rights.
Vote to accept PKIFed https://evento.renater.fr/survey/results/spjo5v1r 57 federations were active voting members, 25 votes cast from active members, 21 in the affirmative, 4 abstain in total and 1 abstain from excluded voters to regain voting rights.
Vote to accept AlbAnia/eduID.rash.al https://evento.renater.fr/survey/results/24s5oat2 54 federations were active voting members, 32 votes cast from active members, 29 in the affirmative, 5 abstain in total and 1 abstain from excluded voters to regain voting rights.

2019

Vote to accept LIAF, RoEduNetID & CARSI https://evento.renater.fr/survey/edugain-sg-vote-may-2019-l5t28sj3 43 federations were active voting members, 38 votes cast from active members, more than the threshold of 22 in the affirmative and 6 abstain from excluded voters to regain voting rights.
Vote to accept Maeen https://evento.renater.fr/survey/edugain-sg-vote-june-2019-msm56vr0 51 federations were active voting members, 39 votes cast, 30 votes in the affirmative, 4 members regained their voting right, 2 members removed from the active list.
*Vote to accept RiċerkaNet Identity Federation https://evento.renater.fr/survey/edugain-sg-vote-malta-rierkanet-ug7givto 54 federations were active voting members, 47 votes cast, 41 votes in the affirmative (1 duplicate), 5 abstain, zero members regained their voting right, 3 members removed from the active list.
*Vote to accept KRENA Identity Federation https://evento.renater.fr/survey/edugain-sg-vote-kyrgyz-republic-kif-1osjvqz5 52

2015

Vote to accept PEANO: https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-PEANO-Ukraine-16-March-2015-5506b. 36 federations were active, 13 votes were received and all were in the affirmative.
Slovakia? Mentioned in July 2015.
Macedonia? Mentioned in July 2015.
Vote to accept eduID Luxembourg: [false http://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-eduID-Luxembourg-8-July-2015-559d2]. 41 federations were active, 15 votes were cast, all were in the affirmative.
Vote to accept Oman KID: https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-Oman-KID-11-November-2015-56436 42 federations were active, 10 votes cast and all were in the affirmative.

2016

Vote to accept Grid Identity Pool (GrIdP) https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-Grid-Identity-Pool-GrIdP-27-July-2016-57987 41 federations were active, 11 votes cast and all were in the affirmative.
Vote to accept KAFE https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-17-November-2016-582d9 21 federations were active voting members, 14 votes cast from active members in the affirmative. 15 votes cast by excluded voters.
Vote to accept AAIEduMk https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-SG-Vote-6-December-2016-58469 33 federations were active voting members, 17 votes cast from active members, 16 in the affirmative. 9 votes cast by excluded voters and 1 duplicate vote.
Vote to accept an update to the eduGAIN Constitution to v3 https://foodl.org/foodle/eduGAIN-Constitution-v3-Update-585c1 As this is a constitution update all 46 members are able to vote (as per v2 of the Constitution).There were 39 votes in total, 36 in the affirmative, 31 needed to reach a 2/3 majority (which was achieved), 1 duplicate vote and 2 abstentions.

2017

...

federations were active voting members, 30 votes cast

...

,

...

25 votes in the affirmative

...

, 5 abstain, 1 member regained their voting right, 2 members removed from the active list.

2020

...

Vote to accept CSTCloudFederation

https://

...

evento.renater.fr/survey/edugain-sg-vote-china-cstcloudfederation-and-slovakia-safeid-jssrjqwu. 52 federations were active voting members,

...

44 votes cast

...

,

...

20 votes in the affirmative

...

,

...

12 abstain.

...

Vote to accept

...

safeID https://

...

evento.renater.

...

fr/

...

survey/edugain-sg-vote-china-cstcloudfederation-and-slovakia-safeid-jssrjqwu. 52 federations were active voting members,

...

44 votes votes cast

...

,

...

36 votes in the affirmative

...

, 2 abstain, 3 federations regain their right to vote, 3 federations removed from the active list.

* The asterisk denotes the votes were used to determine who is active in future votes from this point forward.

Page tree

Versions Compared

Old Version 11

New Version 43

Key

Summary of votes by the eduGAIN SG

2012

2013

Summary of votes by the eduGAIN SG

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2015

2016

2017

2020