You are viewing an old version of this page. View the current version.

Compare with Current View Page History

« Previous Version 5 Next »

Date

Attendees

Goals

  • Review the TOC and set a course of action to meet the 2016-04 deadline for the MJRA 1.3 Milestone

Discussion items

TimeItemWhoNotes
25minSection 2 Attribute Authority

Christos Kanellopoulos (grnet)

Lalla Mantovani

Davide Vaghetti

  • Christos suggested that it could be good to have the same structure for all the items in Section 2. It followed a short discussion and the following structure emerged as the a viable approach: Models/Technologies/Use Cases/Emerging Patterns/Issues.
  • It is well understood that the Use Cases and Technologies sub-sections are to be completed first; only later, the Models, Emerging Patterns and Issues sub-sections could be really worked out.
5minSection 1 Existing relevant worksChristos Kanellopoulos (grnet)
  • Christos invited to take into account all the previous works on the subject, and first of all MJRA1.1; 
  • A new section was inserted to link the existing relevant works;
25minSection 3 Token Translation Service

Davide Vaghetti

Lalla Mantovani

Christos Kanellopoulos (grnet)

  • Davide pointed out that Token Translation Service (TTS) actually lack a strong definition, so each time we speak about it we have to choose which Technologies are TTS or not (TCS is the most apparent case), so he proposed to create a Definition item in the TTS section;
  • Christos suggested not to divide the items in Section 3 by protocols translations services, but by main topics (like in Section 2); Lalla pointed out that we can change the structure but we should not loose focus on the protocols, since they are the real business of TTS; with all the comments and views in mind, it was agreed to make some modification to the Section 3 to take into account all the hints;
10minSection 4 Attribute Translation

Davide Vaghetti

Christos Kanellopoulos (grnet)

Martin Haase

  • Christos invited not to put too much efforts on Section 4, since that specific topic will be dealed off in greater detail in AARC2;
  • Martin told us that he can gather some information on the current discussion on "Group membership to authorisation";
  • Davide said that the work Section 4 will be informative
10minSection 5 Delegation of Authorisation

Nicolas Liampotis

Martin Haase

Ahmed Shiraz Memon

  • Nicolas suggested that a more formal structure (like in Section 2) could be used for Section 5 too;
  • The initial title of Section 5 — Delegation of Authorisation Management — was deemed somehow ambiguos, it was agreed to get rid of the world "Management", and maybe review it once again after we have some content;
10minSection 6 Non Web Access

Ahmed Shiraz Memon

Davide Vaghetti

  • Shiraz, to avoid duplication of efforts already made in other Tasks (namely the Blueprint), made a proposal to anchor the content of the Non Web Access section to the very topics of JRA1.4, so two items were added in the section: Attribute Management and Token Translation;
10minSection 7 Level of Assurance for attributes

Ahmed Shiraz Memon

Nicolas Liampotis

Davide Vaghetti

  • It still remain questionable if there is the case for LOA for Attributes in JRA 1.4; it was agreed to investigate further and then decide if the section could stay or be deleted;
15minSection 8 ConsentNicolas Liampotis
  • Nicolas proposed to move the Consent content in the Issues items of relevant Section 2 points;
15minAssignments and next VC 
  • Since the VC lasted too long, only few actions could be assigned, there will be a next round of assignments either via aarc-jra1 mailing list or in the next VC;
  • Next VC will be held next week, it follows a foodle on the aarc-jra1 mailing list;

Action items

  • Davide Vaghetti: clean up the TOC; make the modification according to the VC discussion;
  • Davide Vaghetti: give an initial definition of Token Translation Service (to be further reviewed and questioned);
  • Davide Vaghetti: will collect links to existing relevant works for Section 1;
  • Davide Vaghetti: will ask to the people behind CILogon to contribute to the deliverable in the relevant section;
  • Nicolas Liampotis: will take care of point 2.1.2.1 (Idp/Shibboleth);
  • Nicolas Liampotis: will take care of point 2.1.2.2 (Idp/SimpleSAMLphp);
  • Nicolas Liampotis: will give an initial outline to the point 2.3.1 (Attribute Aggregation Services/Models);
  • Ahmed Shiraz Memon: will take care of point 2.1.2.4 (Idp/Technologies/UNITY);
  • Michal Procházka: will take care of sections about Perun and ELIXIR (section 2.2 and 2.3);
  • No labels