Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...


Line/Reference #Proposed Change or QueryProposer / AffiliationAction / Decision (please leave blank)Status
182-83

"...described in section 3.6" appears to be an error. Section 3.5 describes Dispute Resolution

Albert Wu / InCommon

286

The eSC ToR has an additional item under eSC responsibilities that is missing from the eduGAIN Constitution: "Approving, supporting and chairing eduGAIN Working Groups". Is that omission intentional?


Albert Wu / InCommon

3118 - 132

It is unclear from this text who the eduGAIN Service Team reports to, i.e., who oversees the work and performance of this function?

Albert Wu / InCommon

4218 - 219

Both mentions of "... as per section 2.2." seem questionable. Section 2.2 describes the eduGAIN Steering Committee.

Albert Wu / InCommon

5283 and 285

The 2 URLs at these lines begin with "http://". Both redirect to their secure equivalent. It'd be best to point directly to their "https://" equivalents. 

Albert Wu / InCommon

6general

The amended constitution still reads like eduGAIN is only a point of metadata exchange among federations. Is that the intent? Is there any work underway to address other matters essential to trusted and scalable interoperation among entities registered in eduGAIN: broad adoption of interoperability profiles; mappable operating (security, privacy, support, etc) policies? Does eduGAIN intend to take an active role in helping newer/smaller federations grow/mature in their capabilities so that there is parity across federations?

Albert Wu / InCommon

775, 123, 217

'Technical Profiles': is there a difference compared to the 'Technology Profiles'?

Wolfgang Pempe / DFN

8249

'voting list': Does this refer to eduGAIN Membership Votes? If yes, there should be 1-2 explanatory sentences in section  2.3, e.g. "A Member Federation which is absent from two consecutive votes will be removed from the active list for the purpose of subsequent votes. Participating in a vote returns the federation to the active list." (copy+paste)

Wolfgang Pempe / DFN